Trade Remedies Explained: Ep. 4 Building the Case
India’s trade remedy system decides when domestic producers may be protected from injury caused by imports, and how far that protection can go.
This episode takes a step back, to the five building blocks a domestic industry needs to establish before DGTR can open a case.
Episode 4: Building the Case
An investigation begins with a written application by or on behalf of the domestic industry. DGTR does not initiate unless the application has enough support and its evidence is accurate and adequate. The application needs to put five building blocks in place.

Block 1: The product under consideration and the like article
Everything in a case turns on how the product is defined.
The product is defined by its description and characteristics. DGTR’s initiation notices state that customs tariff classification is indicative only and does not bind the scope. Applicants usually include every type and grade they make, to limit room for circumvention later. Types the Indian industry does not make are a common subject of exclusion requests from importers and users.
Against the imported product sits the like article. This is an article “identical or alike in all respects” to the article under investigation or, in its absence, one that “has characteristics closely resembling” it. In practice, DGTR compares physical and chemical characteristics, manufacturing process and technology, functions and end uses, specifications, pricing, distribution and marketing, and tariff classification. The application format asks whether the Indian product is “commercially and technically substitutable” for the imports.
Safeguard cases use a narrower definition: “identical or alike in all respects”, without the “closely resembling” limb. The domestic industry in a safeguard case, however, also covers producers of directly competitive articles.
Block 2: The domestic industry and standing
The domestic industry is the Indian producers of the like article as a whole, or those whose collective output is a major proportion of total Indian production. Producers related to exporters or importers of the product, or that import it themselves, may be left out, and the industry then means the rest of the producers.
“Related” is defined by control. Producers are related to exporters or importers only if one controls the other, both are controlled by a third person, or together they control a third person. The relationship must also give grounds to believe it makes the producer behave differently from non-related producers. Control means being legally or operationally able to exercise restraint or direction over the other.
Industries with a very large number of small producers have a simpler route. All producers file basic injury information, and DGTR may examine a statistically valid sample of them in full.
In anti-dumping (AD) and countervailing (CVD) cases, the application must also be made “by or on behalf of the domestic industry”. With the definition above, this gives three tests of equal weight:
1. Major proportion. The producers forming the domestic industry account for a major proportion of total domestic production of the like article. The Rules set no figure; DGTR assesses it case by case.
2. At least 25%. Domestic producers expressly supporting the application account for at least 25% of the total production of the like article by the domestic industry.
3. More than 50%. Supporters account for more than 50% of the production of the portion of the domestic industry expressing either support for or opposition to the application.

Applicants and supporters together hold 40% of total production, which clears the 25% test. Of the 55,000 tonnes held by producers taking a view, they hold 40,000, or 73%, which clears the 50% test.
Support must be shown in data, not by letter. Each supporting producer files its information in a prescribed format.
In safeguard cases, the domestic industry is the producers of the like or a directly competitive article, as a whole or a major share of production. There is no related-producer exclusion, and the Safeguard Rules set no numerical standing test: the application must be made by or on behalf of the domestic producers.
Block 3: The Evidence
Before initiating, DGTR examines the accuracy and adequacy of the evidence in the application. It initiates only if satisfied that there is sufficient evidence of dumping, injury and a causal link to justify an investigation.
The standard at this stage is prima facie evidence. Simple assertion, unsubstantiated by relevant evidence, is not enough (WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement, Article 5.2). But the applicant does not need evidence of the quantity and quality required for a preliminary or final finding. Proof builds up as the investigation moves forward, through questionnaire responses, verification, hearings and disclosure. If the evidence falls away along the way, DGTR terminates the investigation.
An AD or CVD application rests on data for set periods. The period of investigation, in which dumping or subsidy is examined, is normally 12 months. DGTR may accept 6 to 18 months for reasons recorded in writing, and the period may be no more than six months old on the date of initiation. The injury period covers the three preceding financial years plus the period of investigation. There may be overlap between them, but no gap.
Illustratively, a period of investigation from April 2025 to March 2026 sits with
financial years 2022–23, 2023–24 and 2024–25, and supports an initiation up to the end of September 2026. The Safeguard Rules contain no equivalent provision.
The application itself follows prescribed formats:
Import data. The applicant obtains transaction-wise import data from DGCI&S against an authorisation letter from DGTR, valid for 30 days. It must tell DGTR within 90 days if it decides not to file.
Costs and performance. Costing formats cover the injury period, with the claimed non-injurious price. DGTR does not take an application on record until it is fully documented.
Support. Each supporter’s data, in the prescribed format and certified.
The evidence must clear minimum thresholds. Below them, DGTR terminates the investigation.

A case also ends if the injury is negligible. The Rules set no figure for negligible injury; it is judged on the facts of each case. How DGTR calculates the dumping margin is the subject of Episode 5.
Block 4: Injury
In AD and CVD cases, the imports must cause or threaten material injury to an established Indian industry, or materially retard the establishment of an industry. There are three forms:
Material injury, shown in the industry’s performance over the injury period.
Threat of material injury, which must rest “on facts and not merely on allegation, conjecture or remote possibility”. The change in circumstances must be “clearly foreseen and imminent”. DGTR considers the rate of increase in imports, the exporters’ spare or growing capacity, the price effect of the imports and inventories.
Material retardation, where imports hold back the establishment of a new industry in India.
The injury analysis begins with the imports themselves. DGTR considers whether dumped imports have increased significantly, in absolute terms or relative to Indian production or consumption. It also examines their effect on prices: significant price undercutting, or an effect that depresses prices or prevents increases that would otherwise have occurred.
It then examines the impact on the industry, evaluating all relevant economic factors and indices, including 15 named ones: sales, profits, output, market share, productivity, return on investment, capacity utilisation, factors affecting domestic prices, the size of the dumping margin, cash flow, inventories, employment, wages, growth and the ability to raise capital. The list is not closed: the Annexure says “including”.
The WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement adds that no one or several of these factors “can necessarily give decisive guidance” (Article 3.4). DGTR weighs them together; a decline in one or two indicators does not by itself establish injury, and growth in some does not rule it out.
Cumulation. Where imports from more than one country are investigated at the same time, DGTR assesses their effect together only when two conditions are met:
the dumping margin for each country is more than 2% of the export price, and each country’s imports are at least 3% of imports of the like article, or, where countries are individually below 3%, they together exceed 7%; and
joint assessment is appropriate in light of the conditions of competition between the imported products, and between them and the Indian like article.

Cumulation matters because imports that are modest country by country may, taken together, show injury. The CVD Rules apply the same approach, using the subsidy and volume thresholds.
Safeguard cases use a higher standard: serious injury, meaning “a significant overall impairment in the position of a domestic industry”, or a threat of it, meaning “a clear and imminent danger”. DGTR evaluates all relevant objective and quantifiable factors, in particular the rate and amount of the increase in imports, their share of the market, and changes in sales, production, productivity, capacity utilisation, profits and losses, and employment. Material retardation and cumulation are AD and CVD concepts.
Block 5: Causation
Injury alone is not enough. It must be shown, on the evidence, that the dumped imports are causing it. DGTR must also examine any known factors other than the dumped imports that are injuring the industry at the same time, and injury caused by them “must not be attributed to the dumped imports”. The factors listed include:
the volume and prices of imports not sold at dumped prices;
contraction in demand or changes in the patterns of consumption;
trade-restrictive practices of, and competition between, foreign and domestic producers;
developments in technology; and
the export performance and productivity of the domestic industry.
The same principle applies in CVD cases and in safeguard cases. Under the Safeguard Rules, where other factors are injuring the industry, that injury is not attributed to the increased imports, and DGTR may refer the complaint for an anti-dumping or countervailing investigation instead. Importers and users can contribute here, by placing evidence of other causes on the record.
Choosing the Remedy
The evidence also decides which instrument fits:
Anti-dumping duty, on imports from named countries, where export prices are below normal value, usually the price in the exporter’s home market.
Countervailing duty, on imports from named countries, where a specific subsidy from the exporting government benefits the exported goods.
Safeguard measure, on imports from all sources, where imports have risen, in absolute terms or relative to Indian production. No unfair practice is required.
A safeguard application must also include a statement of the efforts the industry is making, or plans to make, to adjust to import competition. The same situation of dumping or export subsidy cannot attract both an anti-dumping and a countervailing duty.
Conclusion
An application stands on five blocks. The product definition sets the scope of everything that follows, including the like article and the domestic industry. The domestic industry needs to hold a major proportion of production and, in AD and CVD cases, support must clear 25% of total production and more than half of the output of those taking a view, shown in data rather than letters. The evidence must be enough to justify initiation, be recent, clear the minimum thresholds, show injury across factors weighed together, and separate the effect of the imports from other causes. A gap in any block can keep a case from starting, or end it later. For an applicant, that translates into a short checklist:
1. Define the product and every type it covers.
2. Check which types the Indian industry does not make.
3. Show that the Indian product is a like article.
4. Identify the domestic industry and any related producers.
5. In AD and CVD cases, file supporters’ data in the prescribed format.
6. Back every claim with evidence, not assertion.
7. Choose a recent period of investigation.
8. Obtain import data through DGTR’s authorisation.
9. Show injury, and that the imports, not other factors, caused it.
Next in the Series
Episode 5: Calculations. How DGTR calculates and sets duties, and treats non-market economies.
Episode 6: After the Duty. Reviews, circumvention, absorption, refunds and appeals: what can happen once a measure is in force.
Earlier in the Series
Episode 1: What Are Trade Remedies? India’s three instruments: anti-dumping, countervailing and safeguard measures.
Episode 2: Procedure and Timelines How an investigation runs, from application to appeal.
Episode 3: Facing an Investigation The rights and obligations of exporters, importers and users once a case begins.
References
Customs Tariff Act, 1975, Sections 8B, 9, 9A and 9B(1)(a)
Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995, Rules 2(b), 2(d), 5, 11, 14 and Annexure II
Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Countervailing Duty on Subsidised Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995, Rules 2(b), 2(ca), 6, 13, 16 and Annexure I
Customs Tariff (Identification and Assessment of Safeguard Measure) Rules, 1997, Rules 2(e), 5 and 8
WTO Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the GATT 1994 (Anti-Dumping Agreement), Articles 3.4 and 5.2
DGTR Trade Notices 2/2004, 13/2018, 05/2021, 09/2021, 11/2021 and 01/2022
DGTR, Compendium of Laws (updated to 16 June 2026)
DGTR, Compendium of Trade Notices (September 2026)
This article is general information on Indian trade remedy law and is not legal advice. The figures used as illustrations are hypothetical. Statements marked as DGTR practice describe how DGTR usually proceeds and are not requirements of the Rules.


Comments