top of page

Trade Remedies Explained: What Are Trade Remedies?

Writer: Satish TD
Satish TD
Oct 14
8 min read

India's trade remedy system decides when domestic producers may be protected from injury caused by imports, and how far that protection can go. It rests primarily on three instruments: anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties and safeguard measures. Each instrument responds to a different cause, but all rest on one common requirement: the imports must be shown to injure the domestic industry.


Through this six-episode series, Trade Law Observatory will explain trade remedy law and practice in India, using easy-to-understand illustrations and examples. Later instalments will take up specific issues in greater depth.


Let's begin.


Episode 1: What are trade remedies?

Take a hypothetical case. Suppose you run an Indian company that makes radial tyres for trucks and buses. You buy natural rubber, carbon black and steel cord, some locally and some through imports, and you sell your tyres to vehicle makers, fleet operators and dealers in India and abroad. Your prices cover your costs and leave a reasonable profit.


Tyre makers in Malaysia see India as a growing market and begin shipping the same sizes here. Their tyres land in India well below your price. Cheaper imports are not, in themselves, a problem: buyers and users gain, and competition is the purpose of open trade.


The position changes if the low price is the result of something the rules treat as unfair, or if imports rise so fast that your business cannot absorb them. Over a year or two, the signs appear in your own records: dealers switch to imported tyres, you cut prices to keep customers, margins shrink, and production lines stand idle.


Trade remedy law addresses that situation, but it asks a narrower question. Is the low price the result of a practice the rules treat as unfair, or of a surge the industry cannot absorb? And is it causing real harm?


This article explains how Indian law answers those questions, using the tyre example throughout.

Trade remedies are permitted departures from India's WTO tariff commitments, and three WTO agreements set their limits: the Anti-Dumping Agreement (implementing Article VI of GATT 1994), the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures, and the Agreement on Safeguards (implementing Article XIX).


India gives effect to them through the Customs Tariff Act, 1975: Section 9A for anti-dumping duty, Section 9 for countervailing duty and Section 8B for safeguard measures, each with its own set of rules. Safeguard quantitative restrictions sit separately, under Section 9A of the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992. Some of India's free trade agreements also provide a separate bilateral safeguard mechanism.

  • Investigation and recommendation: the Directorate General of Trade Remedies (DGTR), in the Department of Commerce, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, conducts the investigations and recommends measures.


  • Imposition: the Ministry of Finance decides whether to impose a measure.


  • Challenge: appeals against DGTR's determinations lie to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), where a Special Bench of the President and at least two members, including one judicial and one technical member, hears them.

Anti-dumping (AD) duty: unfair pricing. Suppose the Malaysian tyre maker charges Indian buyers less than it charges for the same tyre in its home market. That is dumping. Sometimes the home-market price cannot be used: there may be no sales in the ordinary course of trade, or a particular market situation or low sales volumes may not permit a proper comparison. Normal value is then based on the export price to an appropriate third country, or constructed from the cost of production plus selling, general and administrative costs and profit. Anti-dumping duty cannot exceed the margin of dumping so determined.


Countervailing (CVD) duty: foreign subsidies. Here the question is whether a government has given the Malaysian tyre maker something of value. A subsidy is a financial contribution by a government or public body, or income or price support, that confers a benefit. This could include a loan below market rates, a tax concession, or an input supplied by a state-owned company at less than its market price. Only specific subsidies can be countervailed: those tied to export performance or to the use of domestic over imported goods, or limited to certain enterprises or industries. The duty cannot exceed the amount of subsidy, and the same situation of dumping or export subsidisation cannot attract both duties.


Safeguards: a surge in imports. Now suppose nothing is unfair about the imported tyres, but imports from several countries increase sharply, in absolute terms or relative to Indian production, and cause or threaten serious injury. A safeguard requires no unfair practice by any exporter. Unlike anti-dumping and countervailing duties, a safeguard measure applies to imports from all sources, subject to an exclusion for developing countries with small import shares. It may take the form of a duty, a tariff-rate quota or a quantitative restriction, and its purpose is to give the industry time to adjust.

Whichever instrument is used, cheap imports are never enough on their own. Every case must answer four questions.


  1. Like article. Are the tyres made in India identical to the imported tyres, or do they have characteristics closely resembling them? In safeguard cases, the test extends to directly competitive products.


  2. Domestic industry. Do the Indian tyre makers applying for protection account for a ‘major proportion’ of Indian production? In AD and CVD cases, the application must also have enough support: producers expressly supporting it must account for at least 25% of total production, and for more than 50% of the output of those expressing a view.


  3. Injury. AD and CVD duties require material injury, its threat, or material retardation of the establishment of a new industry. Safeguards require serious injury, a significant overall impairment of the industry, or its threat.


  4. Causal link. Did the imports cause the injury? Harm from other factors, such as a slowdown in truck sales, a change in technology or the industry's own performance, cannot be attributed to the imports.


Injury is shown through the industry's own data. In AD and CVD cases, DGTR examines import volumes, the effect of imports on Indian prices through undercutting, depression or suppression, and the impact on sales, output, profits, capacity use and employment. In safeguard cases, it looks at the rate and amount of the increase in imports, the market share they take, and changes in the industry's sales, production, productivity, profits and employment. If the evidence shows neither injury nor its threat, there is no measure.

For AD and CVD duties, DGTR calculates two figures: the dumping or subsidy margin, and an injury margin, which measures how far imports land below the price the Indian industry needs. The duty is set at the lower of the two, so that it is enough to remove the injury and no more.


For countervailing duties, the CVD Rules require this: the duty cannot exceed either the amount of subsidy or the amount adequate to remove the injury. For anti-dumping duties, the Rules cap the duty at the dumping margin and direct DGTR to recommend the amount that would remove the injury. Safeguards carry no margin. The measure is set at the level needed to prevent or remedy serious injury and to facilitate adjustment, and where it lasts more than a year, it must be progressively liberalised.


The benchmark for the injury margin is the non-injurious price. The WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement says only that a lower duty is desirable if it is adequate to remove the injury; it does not say how that level is measured. Annexure III to India's Anti-Dumping Rules answers that question: the non-injurious price is the efficient cost of production of the Indian industry, based on the best use of raw materials, utilities and capacity, plus a reasonable return on capital employed. Extraordinary costs, post-factory selling costs and taxes are excluded, so the industry is not rewarded for its own inefficiency.


Illustration: Each instrument is treated as a separate hypothetical case:

Step

Calculation

Result

Anti-dumping: the Malaysian exporter prices below normal value

Dumping margin

Normal value (200) − export price (140)

60

Injury margin

Non-injurious price (180) − landed value (150)

30

Anti-dumping duty

Lower of the two

30

Countervailing: the Malaysian exporter receives a specific subsidy

Subsidy amount

Loan below market rate (12) + tax concession (8)

20

Injury margin

Non-injurious price (180) − landed value (150)

30

Countervailing duty

Lower of the two

20

Safeguard: imports from all sources surge, with no unfair practice

Margin

None: there is no unfair price or subsidy to measure

Not applicable

Level of the measure

What is adequate to prevent or remedy serious injury and facilitate adjustment, set on the evidence

20%

Progressive liberalisation

Required where the measure lasts more than one year

20%, 18% and 16% over three years

A duty may take three forms or a combination of them. They can be a fixed amount per unit, a percentage of the assessable value, or the difference between a reference price and the landed value, payable only when imports land below that reference price. These forms reflect how DGTR recommends and the Ministry of Finance notifies duties; they are not prescribed in the Act. Safeguards may also limit volumes through a tariff-rate quota or a quantitative restriction.


Not every case qualifies, and no measure is permanent:


Anti-dumping

Countervailing

Safeguards

De minimis margin (no duty if below the margin)

Below 2% of export price

Below 1% ad valorem (2% for developing countries)

No margin test

Negligible imports (case terminated/not conducted)

A country below 3% of imports, unless such countries together exceed 7%

Negligible volume; for developing countries, below 4%, unless together above 9%

Developing countries at 3% or less excluded, if together 9% or less

Initial term

5 years

5 years

4 years

Extension

Up to 5 years at a time, after a sunset review

Up to 5 years at a time, after a sunset review

Where the industry is adjusting; never beyond 10 years in total

The three instruments differ in cause, in reach and in the injury they require. AD and CVD duties answer specific conduct, so they name countries and set rates exporter by exporter, and they require material injury. Safeguards answer a surge, even where imports are not unfair, so they apply to all sources and demand serious injury. What unites them is the discipline the law imposes: a proven cause, demonstrated harm, a causal link, a measure no larger than needed, and a fixed end date.


For the tyre maker in our example, the first task is to identify why the imports are cheap; the second is to show, with its own data, that they are causing the harm.

  1. Customs Tariff Act, 1975, Sections 8B, 9, 9A, 9B and 9C

  2. Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995, Rules 2, 5, 11, 14, 17, 18 and Annexures I–III

  3. Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Countervailing Duty on Subsidised Articles and for Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995, Rules 2, 6, 13, 16 and 20

  4. Customs Tariff (Identification and Assessment of Safeguard Measures) Rules, 1997, Rules 2, 4, 8, 11 and 13

  5. Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992, Section 9A

  6. WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement, Article 9.1; Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures; Agreement on Safeguards

  7. DGTR, Compendium of Laws (updated to 16 June 2026)

  • Episode 2: Procedure and Timelines. How an anti-dumping, countervailing or safeguard investigation moves in India, from application to appeal.


  • Episode 3: Facing an Investigation. What exporters, importers and user industries can do, and must do, once DGTR initiates a case.


  • Episode 4: Building the Case. Product scope, like article, standing and injury: what a domestic industry must establish before DGTR will act.


  • Episode 5: Calculating Dumping. How DGTR sets normal value and export price, compares them fairly, and treats non-market economies.


  • Episode 6: After the Duty. Reviews, circumvention, absorption, refunds and appeals: what can happen once a measure is in force.




Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page